Plato's objection to poetry and aristotle's defence 1 plato's objection to poetry & aristotle's defence: theory of mimesis department of english mk bhavnagar university [email protected] Unlike plato, aristotle regards poetry as something positive in his poetics we will write a custom essay sample on aristotle's defense of poetry against plato specifically for you. Poetics aristotle p 2a poetics aristotle p 2b aristotle on the art of poetry opportunity to make her defence in plain prose and show that she translated by ingram bywater.
This article challenges the view that aristotle's poetics provides a defense against plato's assault on poetry i argue that aristotle's discussion of poetry is at least as critical of the poetic. Aristotle's poetics can be read as a response to plato's attack on art aristotle (384-322 bce) was a student at plato's academy from the time he was seventeen until plato's death some twenty years later. Aristotle received his philosophical education at plato's academy, so it is natural that he would feel obliged to justify at length why he departs from the doctrines of his teacher he provides detailed arguments against many of plato's doctrines in almost all of his major works, focusing in particular on the theory of forms. So aristotle with success and, finally, set aside the equivalent of plato, and if the defense of poetry, which has since been in use for the lovers of poetry as a justification for the muse it breathes new life and soul of the concept of poetic imitation, and has shown that it is a reality, the creative process.
In his attack against the culture of his society overall, plato, like many contemporary enemies of popular art, centers on poetry because it was the main means of cultural transmission and because it gave him the strongest case. Ancient greek philosopher aristotle, together with socrates and plato, laid much of the groundwork for western philosophy poetics is a scientific study of writing and poetry where aristotle. Get an answer for 'what is plato's view on poetry and the poetdo you agree with his view give reasons for your answers' and find homework help for other plato questions at enotes. Aristotle's defense of poetry against plato essay barut 311011 2008210003 tkl301/ take-home examination aristotle's defense of poetry against plato in the light of literary criticism as literary critics, plato and aristotle have different opinions on poetry and also it's social effects. Famous philosopher plato didn't look too fondly on art or poetry, believing that all art is simply a reflection of an illusion or shadow of true reality.
His apology for poetry is aspirited defense of poetry against allthe charges laid against it since plato he considers poetry as the oldest of all branches of learning andestablishes its superiority • an apology for poetry is the most important contribution to renaissance literary theory. He defends the family as a social institution against the criticisms of plato it may be tempting to cast aristotle's defense of self-love into modern terms by. Perhaps influenced by the private-property arguments of democritus, aristotle delivered a cogent attack on the communism of the ruling class called for by plato he denounced plato's goal of the perfect unity of the state through communism by pointing out that such extreme unity runs against the diversity of mankind, and against the reciprocal.
Philip sidney in his apology for poetry reacts against the attacks made on poetry by the puritan, stephen gosson to, sidney, poetry is an art of imitation for specific purpose, it is imitated to teach and delight. Aristotle's remark may be understood as a defense of poetry against herodotus's attempt to supplant the political teaching of the poets and the wise men aristotle aligns poetry with philosophy because the poets' political teaching serves the city at the same time that it anticipates political philosophy. Plato's political philosophy plato is generally viewed as one of the greatest and most influential philosophers in the than to have injustice committed against.
Buy a cheap copy of literature against philosophy, plato to book by mark edmundson literature against philosophy, plato to derrida: a defence of poetry by. Plato, a greek philosopher who lived during 420-348 bc in athens, and aristotle, plato's student who argued against his beliefs, have no exceptions to the steps they had to take in order to understand the purpose of art and artists. Ironically it was plato's most famous student, aristotle, who was the first theorist to defend literature and poetry in his writing poetics against plato's objection and his theory of mimesis self-assessment questions (saqs) -2. Plato's the republic especially poetry and drama pericles, in his defense of democracy, gives priority to historical facts over prose: far from.
Poetry, a well-reasoned defense of plato's charges against poetry aristotle takes up hints and suggestions from his great teacher, re-explains them, and gives new meaning and significance to. Aristotle vs plato comparison aristotle and plato were philosophers in ancient greece who critically studied matters of ethics, science, politics, and more though many more of plato's works survived the centuries, aristotle's contributions have arguably been more influential, particul. Plato's objections against poetry and aristotle's replies objection from philosophical point of view 1 art (painting, music and other fine arts) is an imperfect imitation of an imperfect imitation, twice removed from reality, hence a world of shadows and falsehood. Get an answer for 'in defence of poesie, discuss how sidney defends poetry against plato's accusations' and find homework help for other defence of poesie questions at enotes.