The existence of poverty acts as a guarantee for the rich people's status, because if there would be no poor, there would be no identification left for the ri. 1 social and cultural theories of poverty: community practices and social change m lisette lopez [email protected] and carol b stack. Functions of poverty i was going to just type out what my college text says, but then i thought, surely someone else has done this already and a quick search lead me to the original article. Mertonian functional analysis is applied to explain the persistence of poverty, and fifteen functions which poverty and the poor perform for the rest of american society, particularly the affluent, are identified and described functional alternatives which would substitute for these functions and. Best answer: herbert gans reviews the ideas of davis and moore (the 1950/60s theorists on the functions of stratification ie the functions of social inequality) he takes their arguments seriously in this article (see web site below) by rewording their approach as 'the functions of poverty' nevertheless he uses this concept in a somewhat ironic way.
Poverty may resist elimination because society needs it for its own security and well being (dm) the uses of poverty: the poor pay all gans, herbert j. Commentary and debate comment on gans's the positive functions of poverty on behalf of functional analysis, gans (1972) has set out to accomplish. (h) gans, the uses of poverty people usually do not see being poor as having a purpose, most people believe being poor is something everyone is trying to avoid, but the truth is that the lower class does serve a purpose in todays society. Gans, h j (1972) the positive functions of poverty american journal of sociology, 78, 275-289 because poverty serves all these functions and more, according to.
Uses of the underclass in america by herbert j gans intro 5- the only certain way to eliminate both this notion and the functions is to eliminate poverty. I think that this can be applied as part of the functional analyses of many of society's issues (ie modern racism, prisons (justice system), education) and as herbert j gans points out poverty the author even goes into discuss how some of the items i mentioned are directly connected functions of poverty. In the uses of poverty: the poor pay all, herbert gans uses functionalism to arrive at a very dark conclusion about poverty: the structure of a stratified society requires that some degree of poverty is necessary in order for that society to function. Gans' highlighted thirteen functions of poverty first , poverty exists so the people caught in it could perform the dirty work this explains why it is the lower class that performs all the menial jobs for middle and upper class colleagues. Functions of poverty gans a sociologist, argues that society is so preoccupied outwardly with the 'costs' of poverty that it fails to identify the corresponding benefits, or rather, the groups or values who benefit he describes fifteen sets of functions, as follows.
(h) 376-382: gans, the uses of poverty gans presents the functions of poverty, in which he breaks the system of poverty into 13 points i find the very first two points very interesting because they are the most relatable for me. Bringing together the uses of poverty concepts and poverty thinking from different cultures will help further this long overdue sorting process, which must take place on the. Herbert gans papers, 1944-2004 creator: gans, herbert j, so, too, would what he dubbed the positive functions of poverty which, he argued in a widely.
Washington university law review volume 1963 issue 1symposium: land use planning 1963 social and physical planning for the elimination of urban poverty herbert j gans. Gans does not try to document or measure the extent of grinding urban poverty, but says that the labels used in such empirical research too often assume the validity of middle-class norms. Gang - the uses of poverty- the poor pay allpdf gans - the positive functions of povertypdf interação simbólica, etnografia urbana, self e urbanismo: a leitura de hannerz da tradição teórico-metodológica da escola de chicago. However, the positive functions of poverty (1972), his most widely reprinted article, catalogued the benefits the more affluent classes derived from the existence of poverty and the poor gans also continued to write critically about what he called the fallacy of architectural determinism , namely the belief that urban planning and.
Who benefits from poverty there is less pressure on other groups to alleviate poverty gans, herbert 1971 the uses of poverty: the poor pay all. The diverse uses of neoliberalism in contemporary research show that it fulfills both conditions finally, an essentially contested concept must be open , its meaning subject to modification in response to changing historical circumstances. In explaining poverty in the united states, which view, individualist or structural, makes more sense to you gans, h j (1972) the positive functions of.